A damaged carving is not primarily a packing problem or an insurance problem. It is a question about who was holding the risk at the moment the damage happened — and most buyers only find out the answer after they need it.
This is how the mechanism actually works, and the points where claims are lost.
The carrier is not your insurer
The usual assumption about a broken shipment is that the freight company pays. They do have a liability, but it is not insurance and it is nowhere near the value of the goods.
Carrier liability is a default legal regime: it is capped, usually by a formula based on weight or on the number of packages rather than on the invoice value, and it is subject to exceptions. The cap is set by international convention and revised from time to time, so ask your forwarder for the figure that applies to your lane and set it against what you paid. On a heavy stone carving the arithmetic is not close — a per-kilogram limit on a dense object leaves most of the value uncovered.
Two further catches:
- You have to show the loss happened while the carrier had the goods. That means evidence at handover, not at unpacking.
- The carrier owes that duty to the party who contracted them. If you bought FOB and your own forwarder booked the freight, that is you. If the supplier arranged carriage, the claim may not be yours to bring.
What a policy is actually deciding
Cargo insurance answers one question — who absorbs a loss in transit — but it answers it through three separate settings, and a policy can be generous on one and useless on another.
Insured value. The number the policy pays against. Most disputes are not about whether damage happened; they are about whether the declared number was the right one.
Perils. An all-risk policy covers what it does not exclude. A named-perils policy covers only the perils listed, which in practice can leave breakage outside cover unless it was caused by something on that list.
Deductible. This matters more for stone than for most cargo, because the typical loss is one piece rather than a whole consignment. A deductible that looks trivial against a container is significant against a single carving.
Insured value is not the invoice value
Three different numbers get confused here, and the gap between them is where money is lost.
- Invoice value — what you paid.
- Landed cost — invoice plus freight, insurance and duty. What you are actually out of pocket.
- Replacement cost — what it would take to put the same thing back on the shelf.
For most products those three converge. For a hand-carved piece from a single block they do not, because replacement means commissioning a new carving: another block, another production slot, another shipment, and a piece that will not match the one you lost.
Ask what basis your policy uses, and declare on the basis that matches your exposure rather than defaulting to the invoice because it is the document to hand. Pricing a first order works through landed cost, which is the number a claim should be measured against.
Why a chipped carving is the hardest claim to settle
This is the structural problem with insuring carved stone, and it is worth understanding before you buy cover.
Insurance thinks in two categories: total loss and partial loss. A total loss is paid on the insured value. A partial loss is settled on what it costs to restore the goods, or on the difference between damaged and sound value.
A carving with a chipped jaw is a partial loss. But stone does not restore. There is no filler that matches the crystal, no invisible repair on a polished surface, and a piece with a damaged feature is not the piece you ordered. Commercially the loss is total; contractually it is partial. The settlement lands somewhere between a repair estimate that does not exist and a depreciation calculation against a market with no comparable for an object that exists once.
Two things follow:
- Document the damage properly, because the argument will be about degree, not about whether it happened.
- If the piece is genuinely one of a kind, say so in the claim. "Replace it" is not a remedy that exists, and an offer based on a notional market value is worth challenging.
The packing warranty is where most claims die
Nearly every cargo policy carries some form of packing warranty: a condition that the goods were packed to a standard, and a consequence — reduced cover, or none — if they were not.
The trap is that the standard is defined by the policy, not by whether the shipment survived. A method that has worked three times is not evidence that it satisfies the warranty, and the question gets asked at the worst possible moment: after the loss, when the answer is no longer free.
So ask, before production:
- What packing standard does this policy require for fragile goods of this weight?
- Does it specify materials, cushioning depth, or an inner-box arrangement?
- Does it require a third-party inspection, or photographs of the packed carton?
Then put the answer into the purchase order as the supplier's obligation, with photographs of the packed carton before it is sealed. That is cheap to ask for and expensive to reconstruct afterwards. Packing stone for shipping covers the protection side; the point here is that the policy may hold you to a specific version of it.
Signing for the delivery ends most claims
The most common way to lose a perfectly valid claim is a clean delivery receipt.
If you sign for a carton as received in good order and then find a broken carving inside, you have created evidence against yourself. The damage may well have happened in transit, but you told the carrier it had not.
The discipline is short:
- Inspect the carton before signing. Look for crushing, punctures, water marks and re-taping.
- Note any exception on the delivery document, in writing, before you sign. "Carton crushed on one corner" is enough — you are not required to know what is inside.
- If the carton looks sound, photograph it sealed, then photograph it at each stage of opening.
- Keep the carton and all the packing material until the claim is closed. Insurers and surveyors ask for it, and by then it is usually in a skip.
The notice window is measured in days
Cargo policies require written notice of a loss within a defined period, and that period is short — commonly a matter of days for damage that was apparent at delivery, with a longer window for damage that could not have been discovered then.
Two practical consequences:
- Diarise the deadline from the delivery date, not from the day someone finally opened the carton.
- Written notice means written. A phone call to a forwarder is not notice under the policy and will not be remembered in six weeks.
If you import several times a year, keep that deadline where you keep your payment dates, so it is not discovered by accident.
Who insures depends on the term
The Incoterm decides where risk passes, and insurance follows the risk rather than the invoice.
| Term | Risk passes | Who needs the cover |
|---|---|---|
| EXW | At the workshop | You, from the moment it is collected |
| FOB | When it is on board the vessel | You, for the main carriage and everything after |
| CIF | When it is on board the vessel — the same point as FOB | You carry the transit risk; the seller's policy is what you claim against |
| DDP | On delivery to you | The seller carries transit risk; your remedy is contractual |
CIF is the term that misleads people, because it contains the word insurance and because the seller pays freight all the way to your port. Neither of those moves the risk. CIF is a shipment contract, not an arrival contract: risk passes when the goods are on board at the origin port, and everything that happens after that — including the main carriage the seller paid for — is your risk. The seller is obliged to arrange cover, but only at the minimum level the term requires, and it is the seller's policy.
So the goods can be at the bottom of the ocean, paid for by the seller, insured by the seller, and still be your loss. Ask for the insurance certificate before the goods ship and read who can claim under it. If you cannot tell, treat CIF as uninsured and buy your own cover. How to read a carving quote sets out the rest of what each term includes.
Under DDP the seller carries the risk to your door, so in principle you do not need transit cover for that leg. What you do need is a contract that says what happens when a piece arrives broken: replacement, credit, or refund. That is a term of sale, not an insurance question, and it is the one most first orders leave vague. Importing from China sets out the rest of the document set that travels with a shipment.
What to put in the purchase order
Four lines cover most of it:
- Who insures, and from which point. Named against the Incoterm, not described in prose.
- The insured or declared value, and its basis. Invoice, landed or replacement.
- The packing standard the policy requires, stated as a requirement rather than a preference.
- The documents a claim will need: commercial invoice, packing list, delivery receipt, and photographs of the carton sealed and opened.
Agreeing those before production costs a short email. Reconstructing them after a loss costs the claim.
What we can give you
We do not sell insurance and we are not a broker, so we will not quote you cover. What we can supply is the evidence side of a claim:
- Per-piece weights and dimensions, so you declare from a measurement rather than an estimate.
- A commercial invoice at the value you declare, described specifically enough that a broker does not have to guess.
- Photographs of the piece itself before it is packed. For a stock carving, the photographs on the product page are of that piece.
If your policy requires a particular packing standard, tell us before production starts. That is a specification we can build to; it is not something that can be added once the carton is sealed.
The short version
- The carrier's liability is capped and is not a substitute for insurance.
- Declare on the basis that matches your exposure — invoice, landed and replacement are three different numbers.
- A chipped carving is a partial loss on paper and a total loss commercially. Document it, and say why in the claim.
- The packing warranty is the most common way cover fails. Get the standard before production, not after the loss.
- Never sign a clean delivery receipt without inspecting the carton.
- Written notice within days, diarised from the delivery date.
- CIF includes insurance, and that does not mean what it sounds like.
- Under DDP your protection is the contract, not a policy.
None of this is legal or insurance advice, and neither we nor this article can tell you what your own policy says. Read it — or have someone read it for you — before the first shipment rather than after the first loss.