A product description has one measurable job: it should answer the questions a buyer would otherwise have to email you about.
That framing is more useful than any word count, because it converts a writing problem into a checklist. Every question a listing leaves open is either a lost sale — the buyer leaves to find a page that answers it — or an email you now have to write, which costs more time than the sentence would have.
Photography answers what a piece looks like. A description has to answer everything a photograph cannot. Those are different questions, and the second set is where most listings fail.
What a photograph cannot tell you
Look at any well-lit photo of a polished stone skull and try to extract these:
- How much does it weigh?
- Which of those three numbers is the length?
- Is the finish glossy or soft?
- Is the stone natural, or stabilised, or dyed?
- Does it sit flat, or does it need a stand?
- Is the piece in the photo the piece I will receive, or one of many similar?
- Is that colour accurate, or is it a trick of the light?
None of those can be photographed reliably, and every one of them is a decision the buyer has to make. If your listing does not answer them, the buyer is guessing — and a buyer who guesses is a buyer who may later believe they were misled.
The fields every stone carving listing needs
| Field | Why it matters | What its absence looks like |
|---|---|---|
| Material — trade name and mineral | Buyers search by both, and they are not the same word | "Rose Quartz" alone leaves the mineral name unstated |
| Treatment state | The single most common source of dispute | Silence is read as evasion, even when nothing was done |
| Dimensions — L × W × H, with units and a stated convention | Size cannot be judged from a photo | Three numbers with no indication of what they measure |
| Weight, in both unit systems | The buyer needs it for their own shipping | "Lightweight" or nothing at all |
| Finish | Polished, satin and matte are different products | "High quality" |
| What is included | Piece only, or piece with a base | Buyer assumes the stand comes with it |
| Variability statement | Prevents the "this is not what I ordered" email | Buyer assumes the photo is the exact unit |
Seven fields. A listing missing three of them is not short, it is incomplete — and the distinction matters, because padding a listing with adjectives does nothing for any of the seven.
Weight is the field everyone forgets
Weight is the least glamorous field and the one with the most consequences, because it is the only field that changes what the buyer can physically do.
Our range runs from a 1.32 lb (600 g) piece to a 9.08 lb (4120 g) piece — a spread of nearly seven times. That is not a small difference; it is the difference between a parcel one person carries to a post office and one that needs different handling entirely. A buyer who resells online needs the weight to quote their own shipping to their customer. If you do not publish it, they will estimate, and estimates run low, because the buyer is picturing a decorative object rather than a solid block of stone.
Publish it in both units. A US buyer thinks in pounds; the factory specification is in grams; and having both means nobody has to convert and get it wrong.
Dimensions need a convention, not just numbers
Three numbers without a convention are worse than two numbers with one, because they look precise while remaining ambiguous.
Take a piece published as 7.1 × 4.5 × 5.5 in (18 × 11.4 × 14.1 cm). Is 7.1 the length from front to back, the height, or the longest diagonal? For a skull-shaped carving those are three genuinely different measurements, and a buyer planning a display shelf cares about a specific one.
So state the convention explicitly. Two workable options:
- Say what each number is. "7.1 in long × 4.5 in wide × 5.5 in tall."
- Publish the diagonal as well, and label it. It is the number that answers "will this fit", and it is the one buyers cannot derive themselves.
The convention also needs to say where the measurement was taken, because on a carved object the widest point is rarely the base. "Measured at the widest point" and "measured across the base" are different specifications, and on a piece with a protruding jaw the difference can be an inch.
This is worth getting right for a mundane reason: dimensional ambiguity is the kind of error a buyer only discovers after delivery, which is precisely when it is most expensive to resolve.
The treatment line, even when there is nothing to disclose
Every listing needs a treatment field, and it needs to be filled in even when the answer is "none applied".
The reasoning is asymmetric. If you write "none applied", you have made a statement that can be checked and that a buyer can rely on. If you write nothing, the buyer cannot distinguish nothing was done from something was done and the seller did not mention it. Silence does not communicate neutrality; it communicates uncertainty, and uncertainty in a listing is read as concealment.
Our own product pages carry a Treatment row on every SKU for this reason, including the ones where the value is a plain "None applied". The material disclosure guide covers how to establish what the correct value actually is for a given piece, including when a supplier's answer is not good enough.
There is a companion point about natural variation, which deserves its own section below.
The variability statement is the cheapest sentence in the listing
Natural stone is not uniform. Two skulls carved from the same material by the same carver will differ in colour depth, in where the veining falls, and in whether an internal fracture catches the light.
If your listing shows one piece and says nothing about that, then every buyer is implicitly promised the exact object in the photograph. Most will be delighted with what arrives. Some will not, and their complaint will be entirely reasonable, because the listing did promise it.
One sentence prevents this:
> Each piece is carved from natural stone, so colour, veining and internal features vary between individual pieces. The photograph shows the material and finish; it is not the exact unit you will receive.
Two things make that sentence work. It is specific about which attributes vary — colour, veining, internal features — rather than a vague "may vary". And it separates what the photo is evidence of (material and finish) from what it is not (the specific unit). A buyer who reads that and still orders has accepted the variability, which is a very different starting position from discovering it.
If you sell one-of-a-kind pieces, invert it: state that the piece shown is the piece sold, and then actually keep the listing accurate as pieces sell. A "one of a kind" listing that quietly restocks is a claim that has stopped being true. That is the territory covered in what you can and cannot claim about stone — worth reading alongside this, because a description can be complete and still be non-compliant.
Where the variation is severe enough to be a defect rather than a characteristic, the distinction is set out in natural flaws versus defects. A listing should not be asked to paper over that.
Do not copy the supplier's description
The most common way a listing becomes wrong is that it was never really written. It was copied from the factory's line sheet, or from a competitor, or generated wholesale from a spreadsheet.
Three specific things go wrong:
The facts belong to a different unit. A supplier description is often written for a representative piece or an average of a batch. Copy it and you have published measurements that were true of something else.
The adjectives are unsubstantiated. Supplier copy is written to sell, in a different regulatory environment, and the claims in it become your claims the moment you publish them. This is the mechanism described at length in the claims article: the words arrive with the goods, and the retailer is the one who has to stand behind them.
The important fields are missing. Supplier copy tends to be long on atmosphere and short on weight, dimension convention and treatment state — the three things buyers actually need.
The fix is not to write from scratch. Keep the facts, discard the adjectives, and check every number against the piece in front of you. A description assembled from verified fields will be shorter than the supplier's version and considerably more persuasive.
Length is the wrong question
"How long should a product description be?" has no useful answer, because length is an output rather than a target.
The question that does have an answer is: does it cover the seven fields, and does it answer the follow-up questions each one raises? A listing that does that might run 120 words for a simple polished piece and 400 for a monumental commission where the buyer needs to understand what they are committing to. Both are correct.
What you should not do is pad. Every additional sentence that is not answering a question dilutes the ones that are, and buyers scan. If a paragraph could be deleted without removing a fact, delete it.
A pre-publish check
Before a listing goes live, confirm each line:
- Material — trade name and mineral name, both present.
- Treatment — stated explicitly, including when it is "none applied".
- Dimensions — three axes, units in both systems, convention stated, diagonal published if size is a selling point.
- Weight — both unit systems, matching the piece.
- Finish — named, not described as "high quality".
- Included — piece only or piece plus base, stated plainly.
- Variability — one sentence on what varies and what the photo does and does not prove.
- Numbers cross-checked against the actual piece, not the line sheet.
- Adjectives audited — every claim that could be checked, checked.
Nine lines. If a listing fails three of them, it is not a writing problem, it is a missing-information problem, and the fix takes ten minutes per SKU.
What this looks like in practice
A weak listing:
> Beautiful natural rose quartz crystal skull, hand carved from solid stone. High quality polished finish, perfect for collectors or as a gift. A stunning addition to any collection.
It contains one verifiable fact — the material — and nothing a buyer needs. It cannot be checked, and it will generate emails.
A listing built from fields:
> Hand-carved from a single block of natural rose quartz, 7.1 × 4.5 × 5.5 in (18 × 11.4 × 14.1 cm), measured at the widest point. Weight 9.08 lb (4120 g). Soft pink tone with natural internal veining. Hand-polished gloss finish. No treatment applied. Sold as the carving only. Each piece is cut from natural stone, so colour and veining vary between pieces; the photograph shows material and finish, not the exact unit.
Same product. The second one is shorter in adjectives and longer in information, and it answers every question the first one raised. It also, incidentally, protects the seller: almost everything in it is a fact rather than a promise.
The short version
- A description exists to answer the questions a photo cannot. Judge it by coverage, not word count.
- Seven fields: material, treatment, dimensions with a stated convention, weight in both units, finish, what is included, variability.
- Weight is the field that most affects what a buyer can do with the piece, and the one most often omitted.
- State the dimension convention, because three unlabelled numbers look precise while staying ambiguous.
- Publish a treatment line even when nothing was applied — silence reads as concealment.
- One variability sentence prevents the most common complaint in natural-stone retail.
- Never publish supplier copy unedited: its facts belong to another unit and its claims become yours.
If you need the underlying specifications to write from — dimensions, weight, material and treatment state per SKU — ask us and we will send the full sheet for whichever pieces you are listing.